Xhorxhina Bami and Vyrtyte GervallaPristinaBIRNFebruary 10, 202316:31Law establishing a Bureau for Verification and Confiscation of Unjustified Assets, adopted by parliament on Thursday, risks acting under political influences, civil society groups warn.

Kosovo Push to Confiscate Unjustified Assets Raises Concerns

A Kosovo citizen holds a banner reading ‘the state can’t be built by stealing’ during a protest in Pristina, March 22, 2013. Photo: EPA/VALDRIN XHEMAJ

Kosovo’s parliament on Thursday adopted a law on the establishment of the Bureau for Verification and Confiscation of Unjustified Assets, taking a major step towards fulfilling one of the ruling Vetevendosje Movement’s election campaign promises.

“Wealth that is unverifiable is also unjustifiable. Confiscation of such wealth is compensation to the people and contributes to fighting poverty and inequality,” Kosovo Prime Minister Albin Kurti wrote on Twitter after the vote.

Before entering into force, the law must be promulgated by President and published in the Official Gazette.

Although the fresh move to fight corruption is widely welcomed, civil society groups and the opposition have criticised the law, claiming it does not provide proper mechanisms for the institution to be unbiased and apolitical.

The Democratic Institute of Kosovo, KDI, a branch of Transparency International in Kosovo, says the law does not ensure the bureau’s complete independence from political interference and its decision making processes are limited, which was also confirmed by the Venice Commission in an opinion last year.

Vullnet Bugaqku, senior researcher at KDI, told BIRN that, based on the law, a division with the Pristina Basic Court that deals only with these cases will be created.

“Such a conception, of the resolution of these cases only in the Pristina Basic Court, increases the risk that the trials for these cases will last for years and that court procedures will be prolonged, because this court is already extremely burdened with cases,” Bugaqku said.

He added that, based on Kosovo’s current law on courts, the Pristina Basic Court “does not have the competence to try cases of civil confiscation [which will be under the jurisdiction of this bureau] but only criminal confiscation”.

The law creates a mechanism for verifying the assets of public officials as well as their family members and third parties, that is, persons to whom it is suspected that the assets of public officials have been transferred.

The law will be applied to unjustified wealth acquired during the period of exercising the function of the subjects since February 17, 2008, and/or within 10 years of the moment when the subject ceases to exercise their function.

The Bureau will begin the procedure for asset confiscation according to the information it collects from Kosovo institutions and from abroad, natural or legal persons exercising public authorizations, as well as from other persons.

In cases of discrepancy between income and property that exceeds the value of 25,000 euros, the Bureau will send the case to court for possible asset confiscation.

A proposal is submitted to the General Director, who then submits the proposal to the court. The law provides that if the party does not respond to the Bureau’s invitation, and if the value of the property is higher than 25,000 euros, it will be assumed that the property was unjustifiably acquired, and be proposed for confiscation.

The General Director’s many competencies increase the risk of political affiliations and unjust decisions, according to Bugaqku: “The risk may be that the person exercising this function, if they are appointed based on party preferences, may abuse this duty by making proposals for the confiscation of assets against former senior public officials who do not belong to the party… that appoints him”.

The reason behinds such potential risk is that only a simple majority of votes in parliament is needed to elect the future director of the bureau, which “undoubtedly increases the risk of appointing a director who is preferred by the parliamentary majority”.

The court can rule to partially or fully confiscate the assets, or that the assets are justifiable. Once the Bureau submits its evidence, the suspect must prove their assets are justifiable in court. 

The court’s decision on confiscation can be appealed. Bugaqku told BIRN that the law should have guaranteed “the right to appeal at the very beginning of the investigative procedure for asset verification,” and not only after a court decision has been made.

The opposition party Democratic Party of Kosovo, PDK, has said it will send the law to the Constitutional Court for evaluation.

According to Kosovo’s Law on the Constitutional Court, at least ten MPs can send a law to the court within eight days of its approval in parliament. A second option allows the law to be sent to the Constitutional Court within six months of its enforcement. 

Source link: balkaninsight.com